Friday, 30 November 2012

Are the Search Engines guilty of Hypocrisy?

We all have become aware of the fact that Pay-per-Click (PPC) advertisements can be placed above or to the right of the results from a Google or Bing search. Originally, paid adverts were placed only to the right of the search results and were clearly distinguishable from the natural (organic) search results. However, various studies showed that users mainly click results at the top of the search page. As advertisements are the major revenue source for Search Engines, the Ad placement was changed to include adverts above the search results.

It is well known that organic (or natural) search results are based on the search engine algorithm that is designed to rank the displayed search results on merit. This is in contrast to the PPC results that are purely financial (even though there are claims that there is some evaluation of the page content). On the merit basis, searchers should always click on the organic search results if they want the best result from their search.

In particular, search engine algorithms like the most relevant, original, well written etc. content and promote articles that follow the search guidelines to the top of the natural search results. Practices like hidden text and cloaking (where the content shown to the search engine differs from that shown to visitors) in order to improve the ranking of search results is considered to be 'black hat' (or bad) by search engines and can lead to penalties or banning of the offending site (quick rightly).

With this in mind, are not the search engine guilty hypocrisy by placing their adverts at the top of the page for the unsuspecting searcher to click? It can be argued that search engines do identify the advertisements as distinct from their organic results and you can see this if you look closely at Google search results where the advertisements are in a yellow block titled 'Ads related to...'

If you look at Bing adverts, the distinction is not so clear. There may be clues as to which results are adverts but these are well hidden and you can't easily distinguish the advertisement region from the natural search results; and yes the adverts region does start with a small title but in this case it is 'Ads' and it is placed in the top right of the box, not a place that the eye naturally tracks to!

In my opinion the Bing advertisements are 'Black hat' (or bad) and the Google advertisements are only marginally better.If there was a real commitment to separate paid for advertising from organic (natural) search results, then there would be a much better distinction like good strong black border around the paid for advertisements.

Are the search engines are guilty of hypocrisy? you decide, I look forward to your comments.

Wednesday, 9 May 2012

SEO experts should be grateful to Google


Why does Google continually change the face of SEO? This makes the SEO field very difficult to master, so why should SEO experts be grateful?

Why would Google want to continually change the face of SEO? Surely it is in Googles interest to be transparent and to let people know what to do to get to the top.

Google is of course interested in providing high quality search results (i.e. good relevant search results). However, Google don't do this because they are nice people (though I am sure that they are). Google is a company, a business, an enterprise and their primary interest like that of any other business is to make money for shareholders.

Google's main revenue stream is paid for advertising (PPC advertising) and they make an enormous amout of money out of this advertising! Therefore, Google continually strives to increase the revenue from advertising and Google search is the primary vehicle with which to achieve this.

As long as there is a secret element to the Google algorithm and as long as the Google algorithm changes, Google have the control they need to be able to sell more adverts. This will always be the case.

This approach also keeps good SEO experts in business because the only way to keep up with changes is to do this as a full time, dedicated occupation and there is a huge amount of work just keeping up and rolling out the changes. Site owners therefore have little option other than to pay for adverts or employ a competent SEO person if they want to be found on the web through organic search.


Google SEO
Google SEO

The roll out of the Panda update was a clear example of Google flexing its muscles and changing the SEO space. Also, the strong suggestions from Google that
  • site owners need to keep up with the continual changes (announced on the Official Google Webmaster Central Blog) and
  • agility to change is key (i.e. ability to make the changes quickly once these are announced).
This further emphasises that change is here to stay and there can never be a 'perfect algorithm' (even if it was possible) because change is the enabler that drives Google's main revenue stream.

By Clinton Dickerson
Co-Founder of CreatorSEO and myinfo.ie
Consultant for SEO Limerick

Tuesday, 10 April 2012

DMOZ - what is wrong with the Open directory?

DMOZ or the open directory was intended to organise the web. This directory is owned by Netscape, maintained by a community of volunteer editors and was reported to be 'supported' by Google.

The submission rules for getting listed on DMOZ are strict and while it may be considered to be good for SEO to be listed on the Open Directory, it can be very difficult to be get listed in the appropriate category on DMOZ. In recent years, there has been the suggestion that DMOZ has become insignificant and is of little value to SEO.

So what happened?

Initially Google 'supported' DMOZ by using information and links on DMOZ to supplement the Google search database. There even was the belief that listing on DMOZ is a factor in the Google ranking algorithm. Consequently, website owners considered getting listed on DMOZ to be essential for search engine ranking position (SERP).


In 2000 Google created its own directory and used DMOZ as the main source for the Google directory however, a decade later (late 2010), the Google directory was shut down and Google stopped supporting directory search. The writing was on the wall, being listed on DMOZ for had little value for Google SERP and as Google is by far the primary player in the search sphere, DMOZ became less relevant.

Aside from SERP, have you ever tried to be listed? It can take years to be listed in a popular category even if this is the most appropriate category for your site. This is especially the case if the editor doesn't take the volunteering task seriously or is overwhelmed by the number of listing requests received. Therefore, the 'volunteer' aspect of the editors of DMOZ is most likely to be the biggest contributor to the loss of popularity of DMOZ and may ultimately lead to its demise.

In defence of the editors, the ratio of websites to volunteers has increased over the years and inclusion requests can easily become burried in the editors inbox. It is understandable then that web site owners are likely to give up on submitting their sites if these are never listed and if DMOZ is unable to keep up with new sites. The logical outcome will be that these newer sites which could be more relevant may never get listed. If this is the case, then DMOZ itself becomes nothing more than a huge list of sites that is difficult to search and is not entirely relevant.

Is this a real effect?

Visitors to a site are always a good indicator of the popularity of the site and it is fair to say that a reduction in the number of visits is a good indication of a loss of popularity. Alexa provides a number of metrics that you can access for most sites including DMOZ (http://www.alexa.com/siteinfo/dmoz.org). Below is a chart from Alexa showing the estimated percentage of visits to DMOZ from a search engine. If you don't like this metric, try the other options on DMOZ. Either way, you are likely to come to the same conclusion, namely that DMOZ is becoming less popular.
DMOZ search trend

The bottom line...

The bottom line for me is that, whether or not DMOZ is important for ranking, the effort in chasing a ranking is not worth the return for SEO and therefore, I consider DMOZ to be a waste of time for SEO after the first submission.

What can be done?

DMOZ needs to re-discover itself.  It needs to find better more efficient ways of getting sites listed. If the human volunteer aspect of getting listed on DMOZ is to remain, then there needs to be more humans, better vetting tools, and improved checks on the volunteer editors. Visible metrics for each submission category may help. How about a measure of how many days on average for a site to be listed and/or the number of outstanding submissions? Why not find a way to incentivise the editors to keep on top of the task? This may even encourage others to become editors.

In the modern web world where engaging with people is central to any web experience, DMOZ needs to find some way of interacting / engaging with users and giving more than just some obscure listing somewhere in a mammoth database.

The potential is there, all that is needed are some new ideas.

Clinton Dickerson on Google+

Sunday, 5 February 2012

Top 5 SEO

Everyone who has an insight into SEO has an opinion as to what are the best 5 things you can do to improve your Search Engine ranking.  I believe that any top 5 must not be absolute and should be defined in relation to the family of sites that are under consideration. For example, the top 5 SEO techniques for newly launched private web sites will be very different from the top 5 for well established sites in a very competitive business market.
Why the top 5 and not top 10, 20 or more? I believe that optimisation should be done in bite sized chunks and 5 is my 'bite size'. So, these are my top 5 techniques for newly launched sites (Part 1). In subsequent articles, I will provide part 2 for new sites and will deal with other families of web site.

Before you start...

Before you can optimise any page on a site, you need to spend some time deciding which words or phrases you want the to achieve a high ranking on. Don't only think about single words, think about search phrases because people search on phrases and it is easier to rank on phrases than individual words. Try to find 3 or 4 phrases for each page.

Top 5 techniques (New Web Sites - Part 1)

Use the title tag

While tags are not directly visible and there is a lot of debate over the use of keyword tags, the title tag is one of the most important components on the web page. The title tag is visible as the heading on the browser tag and the title tag is used by search engines to determine the topic of the page. Make sure that the title tag is distinct for each page on the site and ensure that the title tag is pertinent to the content on the page. Also, make sure that your most important keyword is included in the title tag.

Optimise your page content

The content on the page contains the words that search engines will use to index the site and to determine a ranking for the page in terms of these words. Consequently the relevance of the words, the word frequency, the proximity of different words to each other and msot important the position of the words on the page are factors that need to be considered when developing content for the page.  While it is important to develop your content with these factors in mind, you should not optimise your pages for search engines, they must be optimised for your target audience.

Don't put too much information on the page

If your page gets too long, split it. Think of the page as a container. If you keep the contents of each container clearly defined, it will be much easier to find what you want in all your containers. The same applies for search engines.  If you find that it is difficult to restrict yourselt to only 4 key phrases, and you feel that you need more key terms or phrases then it is likely that you have too much on the page.  Too much information is likely to dilute your key messages which then may lead to a lower ranking for all your key terms.

Include links to and from your site

Include links to authorative sites from your page where this is pertinent. Also try to get yous site referenced from other sites.  However be careful not to use link farms of dubious sites that are prepared to link to you. You could even be penalised if you have too many 'bad sites' that link to your page. The value of the incoming link is only as good as the site that the link is coming from, so try to get authorative links. One approach to getting good links is to write articles or blogs on other unrelated sites and to reference (link back) your page from these articles or blogs. Bear in mind, when you link out from your page, you sould set the target to a new page so that you do not take your reader away from your page.

Avoid any black-hat techniques

Developing page content primarily for search engines is likely to lead to black hat techniques. Black hat techniques include repeating words too often (keyword stuffing or keyword spamming); invisible text on the page containing keywords; fake pages that transfer the user to some unintended location. Don't be tempted by black hat techniques because these can penalise of disqualify a site from the major search engines.