It is well known that organic (or natural) search results are based on the search engine algorithm that is designed to rank the displayed search results on merit. This is in contrast to the PPC results that are purely financial (even though there are claims that there is some evaluation of the page content). On the merit basis, searchers should always click on the organic search results if they want the best result from their search.
In particular, search engine algorithms like the most relevant, original, well written etc. content and promote articles that follow the search guidelines to the top of the natural search results. Practices like hidden text and cloaking (where the content shown to the search engine differs from that shown to visitors) in order to improve the ranking of search results is considered to be 'black hat' (or bad) by search engines and can lead to penalties or banning of the offending site (quick rightly).
With this in mind, are not the search engine guilty hypocrisy by placing their adverts at the top of the page for the unsuspecting searcher to click? It can be argued that search engines do identify the advertisements as distinct from their organic results and you can see this if you look closely at Google search results where the advertisements are in a yellow block titled 'Ads related to...'
If you look at Bing adverts, the distinction is not so clear. There may be clues as to which results are adverts but these are well hidden and you can't easily distinguish the advertisement region from the natural search results; and yes the adverts region does start with a small title but in this case it is 'Ads' and it is placed in the top right of the box, not a place that the eye naturally tracks to!
In my opinion the Bing advertisements are 'Black hat' (or bad) and the Google advertisements are only marginally better.If there was a real commitment to separate paid for advertising from organic (natural) search results, then there would be a much better distinction like good strong black border around the paid for advertisements.
Are the search engines are guilty of hypocrisy? you decide, I look forward to your comments.
No comments:
Post a Comment